Scam Number ListDialer
Home · Medicare Card Fraud · Area 440 · (440) 557-5841
Reported phone number · Impersonating Medicare / CMS

(440) 557-5841

High Risk · Risk 65/100
Total reports
9
Impersonated agency
Medicare / CMS
Origin (caller ID)
Ohio
Last reported
2026-04-24
Live callerFree equipment pitchAsks for Medicare IDTargets seniors

Add your report → More Medicare Card Fraud numbers →

What callers from (440) 557-5841 say

Caller offered a free back brace if I verified my Medicare ID and shipping address. When I asked who they were they hung up.

Why this matters: calls from this number have appeared in our directory 9 times across 3 distinct user reports between 2024-07-09 and 2026-04-24. Multiple independent reports describing the same script are a strong signal that the number is being used by an organized Scam Number List operation rather than a one-off mistake or wrong-number call.

The script associated with this number falls under our Medicare Card Fraud category, where the caller pretends to represent the Medicare / CMS. Read the category page for the broader pattern this fits into and how to verify whether you are actually being contacted by the agency in question.

If you answered the call: a step-by-step guide to what to do in the next 24 hours covers credit freezes, agency reporting, and which contacts to update first if you shared any personal information during the call.

Where the number is calling from

The caller-ID number reported is (440) 557-5841, with the area code 440 historically assigned to Ohio. That does not mean the call physically originates there. Modern voice-over-IP services let Scam Number Listmers display essentially any number on the recipient's caller-ID screen, and the most common pattern is to spoof a number with the same area code as the person being called so the call looks "local." If you've received a call you believe came from this number, do not rely on the displayed caller-ID as evidence of who actually called you.

If this number is yours

It is genuinely possible that the number on this page is a real, legitimately-owned phone line whose caller ID has been spoofed by a Scam Number List operation without the owner ever placing a call. If that's the case for you, see our contact page for the process to add a clarifying notice or have the listing removed.

Reader Reports

Patricia W. · Ohio 2026-04-24

Friendly woman said my Medicare card had expired and they were sending out new chip cards. Just needed to confirm the number on the front. My Medicare card doesn't expire.

Carlos R. · Ohio 2024-12-21

Called my mother, who is 81. Got her to read out her Medicare ID. We have since locked everything down with SSA and reported to 1-800-MEDICARE.

Anonymous · Ohio 2024-07-09

Said my Medicare benefits would be cut off unless I confirmed my date of birth and ID number. Pure phishing.

Other reported Medicare Card Fraud numbers

Other numbers from area code 440

What you should do if this number called you

  1. Don't call back. The number may auto-route to an overseas call center. Returning the call confirms a working line.
  2. Block the number. Most modern phones have built-in spam blocking; block the full number, not just the prefix.
  3. Report it to the impersonated agency. File a complaint with the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and, if the call impersonated Medicare / CMS, with that agency directly through its official complaint channel.
  4. Tell us. Adding your report helps the next person who searches this number find the warning sooner.